Thinking Citizen Blog — Michigan Rep Justin Amash (Libertarian): Is he doing the right thing? Could he swing the election? Which way?

Thinking Citizen Blog — Sunday is Political Process, Campaign Strategy, and Candidate Selection Day

Today’s Topic: Michigan Rep Justin Amash (Libertarian): is he doing the right thing? could he swing the election? which way?

Who is Justin Amash? For one thing, he is the first Republican to call for the impeachment of Donald Trump (5/19/19). He has been a member of the US House of Representatives since 2011. In July 2019 he quit the Republican Party to become an independent. In April 2020, he joined the Libertarian Party, becoming the first Libertarian ever to hold a seat in Congress. He describes himself as a believer in the Constitution, meaning: “limited government, economic freedom, and individual liberty.” He counts Friedrich Hayek and Frederic Bastiat as his “biggest heroes.” He announced his candidacy for the US presidency on April 28, 2020. Experts — please chime in. Correct, elaborate, elucidate.


1. “Nooo! You’ll be the Ralph Nader of this election!” (Mia Farrow)

2. “Any vote for Justin Amash is a vote for Donald Trump. If he runs he knows he will be helping Trump. If Justin runs he’ll be putting his own interests ahead of the country’s interests. If he runs, shame on him.” (Joe Walsh, former Illinois Congressman and author of “F**** Silence: Calling Trump out for the Cultish, Moronic Con Man He Is”).

3. How could this be? Well, for one thing, Amash is from Michigan, a swing state, that went for Trump in 2016 by only 10,786 votes. Amash could easily prevent a Biden win in Michigan.

NB: “The best and surest way to beat Trump is to have only one alternative to him.” (Joe Walsh, Washington Post, 4/29/20)


1. “…an Amash candidacy could inflict a fatal wound on Trump’s bid for reelection. Many right-leaning voters are weary of Trump, yet will never cast a ballot for Biden. A Libertarian alternative gives them — or rather, us, since I’m in that category — a more appealing option than voting Republican or sitting out the election.”

2. “In almost no field apart from politics are people denounced for providing more than a binary choice. Bartenders stock more than bourbon and vodka. Schwab doesn’t limit investors to Mutual Fund A and Mutual Fund B. No one tells Netflix that adding “Tiger King” to its lineup was wrong because it could only siphon viewers away from “Outlander” and “Never Have I Ever.”

3. “Having more than two choices is nearly always a good thing. It is certainly a good thing in politics. Amash proposes to run for president as a “classical liberal” — i.e., a pro-freedom, limited-government, anti-authoritarian constitutional conservative. He holds himself out as an option for voters seeking a candidate who is “normal, honest, practical, and capable.” Maybe such a candidate can’t win the White House, but voters should be the ones to make that decision.”

THE STATISTICIANS: Amash impact is too tough to call (FiveThirtyEight)

1. “Consider what happened in 2016: In 11 states, Libertarian nominee Gary Johnson’s raw vote total exceeded the vote margin separating Trump and Hillary Clinton. Now, that doesn’t mean Johnson necessarily changed who won in each of those states, but he and other third-party contenders (like Jill Stein of the Green Party) may have helped shape the outcome, especially in the three states that proved decisive in the electoral college: Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.”

2. “there is evidence that more libertarian-minded voters are more likely to vote Republican than Democratic, which could cost Trump at the ballot box.”

3. “Still, an Amash bid could still present problems for Biden, too. If 2020 is a referendum election on Trump’s presidency, Biden may not want another well-known candidate in the race to give potential anti-Trump voters a different choice. Polls have long shown that a majority of voters prefer an alternative to candidate Trump but that doesn’t mean that alternative has to be Biden. So it’s possible that Amash could win over some of these voters, lowering Biden’s ceiling and narrowing the race between the major-party nominees.”

Justin Amash Could Cause Some Trouble In November

Perspective | Joe Walsh: You can’t win, Justin Amash. You can only help Trump get reelected.

Opinion | Justin Amash Can Only Cause Trouble

Justin Amash won’t ‘spoil’ the election, he’ll enhance it — The Boston Globe

Opinion | Is Justin Amash a Threat to Biden or to Trump?

Justin Amash


Please share the coolest thing you learned in the last week related to the political process or campaign strategy or 2020 candidate selection or anything else for that matter.

This is your chance to make someone else’s day or change their thinking.

Or to consolidate in your own memory something worth remembering that might otherwise be lost. Or to clarify or deepen your own understanding of something dear to your heart. Continuity is key to the depth of thought.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store